Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Tate Brothers Tried to Unmask Their Critics — and Hit Another Legal Wall

Andrew and Tristan Tate sued Twitter to get the identities of anonymous critics

Andrew and Tristan Tate wanted the identities of anonymous critics on Twitter, so they filed a separate Florida lawsuit seeking to force the platform to disclose them. That effort has now hit a major procedural obstacle.

A Palm Beach County judge granted Twitter’s motion to dismiss, finding that the Tates’ amended complaint did not adequately establish a basis for exercising specific personal jurisdiction over the company under Florida law. The dismissal is without prejudice, meaning the Tates have 20 days to amend and try again, so this is not yet a final defeat.

But the ruling is still significant. The Tates wanted this case because anonymous defendants create obvious problems in their underlying litigation. Now their attempt to solve that problem has itself been dismissed on jurisdictional grounds.

In this video, I explain the ruling, why personal jurisdiction matters, and what happens next.

Thanks for subscribing and sharing! Please consider upgrading your subscription for additional features.

— Dave, AKA Florida LawMan

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?